Whether a requested accommodation would fundamentally alter an essential requirement of a course will generally need to be determined on a case-by-case basis, in light of the specifics of the course and the requested accommodation. The following general discussion may be helpful to illustrate some of the relevant considerations.
Essential requirements are the outcomes (including skills, knowledge, and attitudes) all students must demonstrate with or without using accommodations.
Some students might use accommodations and some might not, but all students must achieve the same outcomes. Process is important, of course, but not necessarily essential. Focusing on course outcomes will help instructors to define the course’s essential requirements.
The difference between essential and non-essential requirements is similar to the difference between “essential” and “preferred” skills listed in job descriptions. An employer may want to see both sets of skills, but only the essential skills are an absolute requirement of employment.
Similarly, in courses instructors can articulate essential outcomes that all students must demonstrate in order to successfully complete the course, as well as preferred outcomes they hope students will be able to demonstrate.
To determine the essential requirements of a course, consider the following:
Once instructors have determined the essential course requirements they should be able to:
Methods of instruction and assessment can be examined to determine how information is taught and what alternative opportunities are available for teaching and learning the information, format of materials, skills etc.
Flexibility in achieving outcomes may or may not be appropriate depending on the nature of the course and its requirements as the following examples illustrate.
A student with a psychological disorder asks to give a required oral presentation in a sociology course to the instructor in private rather than to the entire class. The accommodation is approved since the essential requirement remains, which is the presentation itself.
This same student requests the identical accommodation in an oral communication class where giving speeches is required. The accommodation in this instance is denied because the fundamental requirement of delivering a speech publicly is essential to the course’s objective.
A student with a learning disability is taking a writing course and asks to use a computer and spellchecker for the in-class final exam. This accommodation is approved because the instructor’s grading rubric does not focus on accurate spelling as the most important element in the essay.
A medical student who has the use of only one hand requests a change in the procedure to start an IV. This accommodation is granted because the student is able to demonstrate proficiency in starting the IV as required by law and/or licensing requirements although he is using a different procedure to achieve this outcome.
Determining what accommodations are appropriate is most effectively accomplished through collaboration.